Hey, I would like to bring to your attention few issues and some features maybe that can be thought about.
Issue -
-
order is sent from stratzy to the broker ( i am using dhan) but the order get failed at dhan. This happened while the strategy is trying to exit a trade. In such a case maybe a retry mechanism or something can be implemented if possible.
-
once in zen credit spread strategy, i had assigned complete 3.2 lakhs capital and according to that 5 lots trade should have been taken( i checked later after trade ended on that particular algo page it was a full capital utilized trade) but on my account somehow only 3 lots were taken. I had raised a chat support for this too but did not get a fair response.
Suggestions -
-
once in a similar credit spread algo itself where we place both buy and sell orders. One order went through and another order was missed because of slippage so the order remained open. Sometimes this can cause an issue in gap situations where in case the option buying part was missed and trade goes against you then can lead to a big loss. So maybe a check if both orders were filled or not or any other solution if you can think of something
-
this was covered in the dhan.dev conference but would still like to put it out there, a black box where strategies are pre selected by you and we are unaware of what’s going on behind the scenes because its difficult to go through so many different algos and understand and select.
For the issues part if any more clarification is required please feel free to reach out to me.
Thanks in advance for the help!!
1 Like
Hello @urvikgala
Thank you for sharing such detailed feedback and suggestions. We truly appreciate users taking the time to highlight both queries and improvement ideas.
- Regarding the order rejected at the broker’s end
If an order is successfully sent from Stratzy but gets rejected or fails on the broker/exchange side, it means the Algo did generate and place the order correctly, however the execution could not be completed by the broker/exchange infrastructure.
For any specific instance, we request you to please share the broker order book and trade details with us at support@stratzy.in so our team can review and clarify the exact reason.
-
Regarding the partial lot execution in Zen Credit Spread
This can generally happen when the available margin at execution time is lower than the capital allocated to the Algo.
Our team had reviewed a similar instance previously and shared the likely explanation based on the execution details available at the time. Since trade behaviour can vary depending on account conditions and broker-side execution, we request you to please share the exact instance again with our support team so we can re-evaluate it thoroughly.
-
Regarding missed legs in spread strategies
Your thought here is completely valid. As per the latest exchange regulations, Algo providers are currently required to place only LIMIT orders. During periods of high volatility or rapid price movement, this can sometimes result in one leg getting executed while the other remains pending.
We understand that this can create risk in spread-based strategies, and our team is already working extensively on improving execution flow, leg management, and retry mechanisms within the framework permitted under the exchange guidelines.
- Regarding the black-box curated strategy experience
Yes, this is something actively being worked on. The concept discussed during the Dhan.dev conference is currently under development and testing. The goal is to simplify the overall user experience by helping users discover and deploy curated strategy setups more easily.
We genuinely appreciate your feedback and participation in the community. Inputs like these help us continue improving the platform and building a better experience for all users.
3 Likes